Peach and apricot growers who supplied Premier's Tulbagh fruit cannery in the Western Cape are disputing the terms of settlements offered after the plant closed, even as Premier reports sharply higher half-year results.

The cannery, Fruit Products Western Cape, is owned by Premier FMCG. It came to Premier through its merger with RFG Holdings. Premier has exited deciduous fruit canning and closed the plant, which was a major buyer of peaches and apricots from Western Cape producers.

What the growers say

The Canning Fruit Producers' Association (CFPA) says producers must end their supply agreements and release claims, including unknown ones, in exchange for payment. It said: "Premier presents these arrangements as support for farmers but does not explain the rights they must surrender."

The association says Premier set a deadline of 5pm on 8 November for producers to accept and refused a request for five more days. It cited one producer who spent more than R3 million expanding orchards by 10.5 hectares, and said "reassurance for a single harvest does not protect them."

Five producers and Premier appeared in the Western Cape High Court on Monday, 9 November. The parties appear to have agreed a consent order that applies only to them. We have not seen the order.

What Premier says

Premier says it has reached settlements worth R65.5 million with 83 peach producers to support orchard removal, delivery of contracted fruit, or a move to alternative markets. It says these settlements "offer financial certainty in exchange for resolving outstanding or disputed claims." It also says producers are not obliged to accept, may pursue their contractual positions through dispute-resolution mechanisms, and that its supply agreements ended when it exited canning.

Premier says the deadline reflected the approaching harvest and the need to arrange fruit volumes, processing capacity and deliveries. It says some producers' contractual positions are the subject of legal proceedings and that it will not debate them publicly.

Speaking after the company's interim results presentation, Gertenbach said Premier concluded voluntary separation agreements with 403 employees at a cost of about R40 million, and agreed to pay R67 million to 82 farmers to remove peach orchards and move to other crops. He said Premier is considering about R40 million of support for its Langeberg cannery, and that both Tulbagh and Langeberg had been running below 50% capacity. He said South Africa "can really only sustain one major fruit canning operation that can compete globally."

The competition case

The Competition Commission wants to revoke its March approval of Premier's R6.5 billion acquisition of RFG Holdings. It alleges Premier withheld material information during the review. Premier denies this and says the closure followed a sharp deterioration in global market conditions, including a stronger rand, a large Greek fruit crop, the bankruptcy of Del Monte and rising competition from Chinese producers.

Premier and the Commission agreed over the weekend of 7 and 8 November to drop an urgent hearing over the closure. The Commission's main case will go to the Competition Tribunal next year. No date has been given. The central question, Gertenbach said, is whether Premier had contemplated closing the factory before 6 March.

Premier's results

For the six months to the end of September, the first period that includes RFG, Premier reported that revenue rose 38.8% to R14.3 billion and operating profit rose 52.5% to R1.7 billion. Headline earnings per share rose 27.1% to 711.1c. The CFPA noted that these results covered the period in which the cannery closed, and said: "A business performing that well has ample room to treat its growers fairly."

What we do not yet know

  • Which settlement figure is correct. Premier has referred to R65.5 million for 83 peach producers and to R67 million for 82 farmers.
  • How many growers have accepted, and how many are still negotiating.
  • The terms of the consent order agreed in the High Court.
  • The date of the Competition Tribunal hearing.