The Auditor-General of South Africa (AGSA) says the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (Prasa) still has R932 million in irregular expenditure, spending that did not follow the required procurement rules, that has not been dealt with. It warned that delays could make the money harder to recover.

AGSA briefed Parliament's Portfolio Committee on Transport and Prasa on its findings, according to reports published on Monday 16 November. The date of the briefing was not stated.

Aphendule Mantiyane of AGSA described the money as "almost a billion rand that has been spent with no value to the entity or the state as a whole". She urged Prasa to deal with the balances quickly and recover the money.

Where the irregular spending comes from

  • General overhaul contracts make up the largest balance. AGSA has escalated the matter to National Treasury. Prasa disputes that the contracts were non-compliant, and management is preparing a request to Treasury to condone the spending.
  • Security service contracts are the second-largest balance. They have been extended month to month since 2020/21 because replacement contracts were delayed.
  • Multiyear contracts have not yet been investigated and may also produce irregular expenditure.

AGSA also identified R19.2 million in irregular expenditure in the 2025/26 audit cycle. Prasa said it has reduced its irregular spending by R23 billion, but the year for that figure was not given.

Governance gaps

AGSA said fruitless and wasteful expenditure has fallen over the years but has not been adequately addressed, partly because of interest charged on late payments. Prolonged suspensions are being considered for write-off, which needs board approval.

The posts of chief procurement officer and chief financial officer are vacant and filled in an acting capacity, which AGSA said poses a risk to sustainable audit outcomes. Mantiyane said the supply chain management unit is understaffed and that there has been "little to no progress" on compliance with key legislation.

AGSA found that effective steps were not taken to prevent irregular and wasteful expenditure, and that investigations to identify the responsible officials were not conducted.

Passenger targets missed

Passenger trips rose 35% year on year to 103.8 million, against a target of 160 million. Prasa missed three targets: Metrorail passenger trips, scheduled train trips and long-distance passengers. AGSA called the shortfall a significant concern. Prasa has set a new goal of 600 million passenger trips by 2030.

What we do not yet know

  • The date of the committee briefing and what MPs resolved.
  • How much of the R932 million Prasa disputes, and whether Treasury will condone any of it.
  • Which officials, if any, will be held responsible, since investigations to identify them have not been finalised.