The National Energy Regulator of South Africa (Nersa) has conceded in the Pretoria High Court that it unlawfully approved electricity tariffs for five municipalities because of significant calculation errors.

The municipalities are Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni and Nelson Mandela Bay, plus Emfuleni in Gauteng and Madibeng in North West. The tariffs concerned were approved for the previous financial year. According to reporting on the case, the figures in the councils' tariff applications contained errors and Nersa approved them without checking. After large electricity users pointed out the errors in court papers, the regulator conceded that its approvals were "indefensible", those reports say.

What the court is asking for

Judge RG Tolmay asked the legal teams on Monday 9 November to formulate a remedy that would prevent a flood of individual court applications. The judge also reportedly raised the option of an independent expert to determine how much customers were overcharged, so that they could be credited without delay.

"The lawyers make money and the taxpayers pay for it," Tolmay told the legal teams. He added: "This cannot go on indefinitely."

Resellers allege a new error in Ekurhuleni

The Electricity Resellers Association of South Africa (Erasa) says Nersa's 2026/27 reseller tariffs for Ekurhuleni, set in July, repeat the mistakes the High Court ruled on in 2025. Erasa chair Johan Hopley says Nersa reduced the retail tariff, which left resellers with no margin.

By Hopley's calculation, a 15% margin in some complexes would become a 17% loss over a year. In Ekurhuleni the electricity account is held in the name of the body corporate, so if electricity revenue falls short of the bulk account, a complex could fall into arrears and face disconnection that affects every unit.

"It is chaos," Hopley said. "You haven't even fixed the first mistake, then you make the next one!" The reports do not include a response from Nersa to Erasa's claim.

Earlier rulings still unresolved

  • The court declared Nersa's 2023/24 tariffs for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Madibeng and Msunduzi invalid and set them aside. The matter was sent back to Nersa, which has not yet redetermined them.
  • Separately, the High Court refused to confirm a settlement between Eskom and Nersa meant to fix a R54 billion error. Nersa's redetermination added 3.4 percentage points to Eskom's average tariff increase this year. AfriForum is challenging it, and the matter has yet to be heard.

What we do not yet know

  • How much too high the unlawful tariffs were, and how much customers were overcharged.
  • Whether refunds or credits will be ordered, and how they would be paid.
  • Nersa's response to the claim that the 2026/27 Ekurhuleni reseller tariffs are flawed.
  • When Nersa will redetermine the tariffs the court has set aside.