The Western Cape High Court has dismissed an attempt by the EFF and the legal association ALPA to overturn Parliament's decision to withdraw the nomination of Advocate Thandazani Griffiths Madonsela as chief evidence leader in the impeachment inquiry into President Cyril Ramaphosa over the Phala Phala matter.
Judge Chantel Fortuin announced the outcome in Cape Town on Friday 13 November. Two judgments were produced: a majority that dismissed both applications, and a dissent that would have granted them.
What the applicants wanted
The EFF and ALPA asked the court to review the decision of Parliament's Section 89 committee to rescind its recommendation of Madonsela. The court accepted the EFF's late submission of legal argument and waived the usual requirements on the service and filing of papers. The hearing took place over two days in October.
The dissenting judgment would have reviewed and set aside the committee's decision, with costs. The majority's reasons and any order on costs have not been reported.
How the nomination came undone
The impeachment inquiry stems from the 2020 theft of foreign currency at Ramaphosa's Phala Phala farm. Ramaphosa has said the money was payment for cattle sold to a businessman.
In a letter dated 18 August 2026, Ramaphosa objected to Madonsela's nomination. He questioned her earlier involvement in the matter, including legal advice she gave the ANC on the impeachment issue. He also pointed to her 2022 removal from the Judicial Service Commission and argued that this could create a conflict of interest.
The committee then withdrew its recommendation and reopened the nomination process. Selecting a replacement was put on hold while the court case ran. The committee had been in the final stages of finalising its terms of reference.
What happens next
Makashule Gana, the committee's chair and a Rise Mzansi MP, said the committee will resume its work and must appoint a new evidence leader. "We need to move ahead and appoint a new evidence leader," he said.
What we do not yet know
- The reasons given by the majority, and by the dissenting judge.
- Whether the EFF or ALPA will appeal.
- Who will be nominated as the new evidence leader, and when the inquiry will start hearing evidence.
- Whether any costs were ordered.



