Developing story: the case returns to court on 23 November and details may change. This article will be updated.
The Musina Magistrate's Court has denied bail to businessman Suliman Carrim, who is accused of attempting to take two financed vehicles out of South Africa. He is presumed innocent until proven guilty, and the allegations have not been tested at trial.
The ruling came on Monday 16 November, a week after the state opposed bail at a hearing that was postponed. The matter returns to court on 23 November. Reports differ on whether that date is for further investigation or for the case to be transferred to the regional court.
Why bail was refused
Magistrate Jerry Davhana found that Carrim had not satisfied the court that he should be released, according to reports. The magistrate questioned why nine properties and eight companies were allegedly not disclosed in his financial records, which raised doubts about the accuracy and honesty of the information he gave the court.
The court also raised concerns about his residential details and his alleged failure to comply with earlier bail conditions set in Pretoria. Reports say the magistrate found that a flight ticket to the United Arab Emirates (UAE) was not enough on its own to show that he would return.
What the state argued
The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) opposed bail and described Carrim as a flight risk. It pointed to his UAE residence permit, alleged undisclosed property interests in Dubai, and his earlier failure to appear before the Madlanga Commission. The state argued this showed he might not comply with court orders.
The state also relied on WhatsApp messages and a letter linked to his co-accused. Questions about the letter's authenticity and the contents of the messages were left to be decided at trial.
NPA spokesperson Mashudu Malabi said the defence disputed the case, arguing that the vehicles were for a temporary family trip and for carrying groceries, and were "not being moved for purposes of theft".
The charges and the background
Reports agree that Carrim faces a charge of attempted theft of motor vehicles. They differ on the other charges: one lists money laundering and employing foreign nationals without work authorisation, while another lists uttering. They also differ on the route the vehicles were allegedly to take. Two other people are co-accused.
Carrim, a former North West ANC treasurer, was arrested at OR Tambo International Airport in October. Separately, the Pretoria Magistrate's Court granted him R100,000 bail on 28 October on a charge of contravening the law governing the Madlanga Commission by repeatedly failing to appear before it. He remained in custody on the Musina matter.
What we do not yet know
- The full list of charges and the vehicles' alleged route, which differ between reports.
- Whether the defence will appeal the refusal or bring a fresh bail application.
- Whether the 23 November date is for further investigation or for transfer to the regional court.



