The Eastern Cape health department, backed by the national health department and the other eight provincial departments, has asked the Constitutional Court to let the state provide ongoing medical treatment instead of lump-sum cash payouts to people harmed by negligence in public hospitals. No hearing date has been reported.
The case behind the application
The province is appealing a Supreme Court of Appeal ruling that set aside an Eastern Cape High Court order. That order would have allowed in-kind treatment for a mother whose child has spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy, which the case papers say was caused by staff negligence at Cecilia Makiwane Hospital in Mdantsane. Advocate Wim Trengove represents the child's family and opposes the state's position. The appeals court said Parliament, not the courts, should decide the issue.
What the state is asking for
- If a patient is negligently injured in a state facility, the state treats the injury at a reasonable standard in its own facilities, under court order, for as long as the injury lasts.
- If the state cannot provide that treatment itself, it pays for private-sector treatment as and when it is needed and received.
The numbers
- The government faces more than R50bn in total medico-legal claims, according to the state's court papers. The Eastern Cape faces claims of nearly R20bn.
- The Eastern Cape, Gauteng and Limpopo account for 74% of medical negligence claims.
- The South African Law Reform Commission has recommended that state payouts above R2m move to structured settlements paid periodically over the injured person's lifetime. It reported that provincial health departments carried R62.4bn in contingent liabilities in 2023/24, while actual payouts to successful claimants totalled R1.5bn.
What each side argues
Eastern Cape Health MEC Ntandokazi Capa says in her affidavit that the country "cannot afford the exclusive application of the lump-sum system in respect of future medical expenses". She argues in-kind treatment gives full compensation without turning future care into cash that could benefit one family and its lawyers at the expense of the wider public health system.
Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi says in a supporting affidavit that a fixed lump-sum requirement is not justifiable given fiscal constraints. He warns that lump sums can deplete provincial equitable shares and says "claims for medical negligence are currently not budgeted for".
Andrew Donaldson, a former National Treasury official now at the University of Cape Town, gave expert evidence that the rise in claims threatens the state's ability to deliver healthcare to more than 80% of the population.
Trengove's affidavit argues the proposal would entrench inequality, because private-hospital patients would keep full common-law rights to lump-sum compensation while public-hospital patients, who are generally less affluent, would not. It says the approach would "favour the affluent and discriminate against the poor".
What we do not yet know
- When the Constitutional Court will hear the matter, and how it will rule.
- Whether Parliament will legislate on structured settlements first, as the Law Reform Commission has proposed.



