In September 2023, forensic auditors told the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) that one of its security contractors had won its share of a national tender with a fake Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF) certificate. The department needed 116 armed guards. The company held 27 firearm licences.
Three years later, on 28 October 2026, the City of Matlosana in North West hired the same company to guard its sites, without a competitive tender.
According to GroundUp, which uncovered the appointment, municipal manager Lesego Seametso signed a letter naming Dephetogo Trading (spelled Dephethogo in DFFE records) as one of four companies to provide physical security services for three months, on an as-and-when-required basis. Documents seen by GroundUp say the municipality used a procurement deviation, a route that bypasses competitive bidding, because its three-year security tender is tied up in appeals and there was a gap in services to fill.
Nothing about the appointment has been shown to be unlawful. Municipal supply chain rules allow a municipal manager to skip a tender in an emergency or where a competitive process is impractical, as long as the reasons are recorded and reported to council. But the company's record, and the state of the municipality that hired it, raise a question that procurement rules exist to answer: how does a contractor dropped by one arm of the state walk into a contract with another?
The tender on hold
Matlosana had advertised a competitive tender for a three-year panel of security providers. In late September, conditional awards were announced. Dephetogo was among the winners.
Losing bidders appealed. Letters from their attorneys, sent in September and October, allege that bidders whose previous contracts had been terminated were evaluated and conditionally appointed anyway, that winning bidders were allowed to fix or add documents after the closing date, that some bid documents were signed by people with no formal authority to do so, and that the pricing and scoring criteria had no rational link to what the tender was meant to achieve. These claims have not been tested. The tender is on hold while the appeals are heard.
The deviation means the work goes ahead in the meantime, and Dephetogo is part of it.
What the auditors found
The company's record with the national government is set out in a forensic report by Morar Incorporated, commissioned by the DFFE and first reported by GroundUp in March 2025.
The DFFE contract, signed in August 2021, covered security at 65 sites over three years. Dephethogo's share was worth about R144 million. Morar found that the UIF certificate in its bid was fictitious, which the Department of Labour confirmed. The bid rules required a control room within 100km of every guarded site. The company had one, in Klerksdorp, and some sites were more than 1,000km away. Officials complained of guards who were drunk or absent from their posts.
The auditors also found that some members of the department's bid evaluation committee changed their scores after advice from supply chain advisers. Without those changes, according to the report, Dephethogo would not have reached the 75% threshold needed to win.
Department officials had warned the company twice in 2022. Morar recommended immediate termination. The director-general signed the termination letter on 29 December 2023, at least two months later. Even then the money kept flowing: seven invoices worth almost R4.3 million, submitted after the contract was cancelled, were all paid. In total, the department paid the company R106 million.
The SIU in Knysna
In August 2026, President Cyril Ramaphosa signed Proclamation 334 of 2026, authorising the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) to investigate tender T25 of 2023/2024 for physical security services at Knysna Municipality, a three-year contract worth R68 million that GroundUp reports was awarded to Dephetogo. The probe covers alleged unfair procurement, improper conduct by officials and suppliers, and losses to the municipality.
On 2 November, SIU spokesperson Selby Makgotho confirmed the investigation is continuing. An SIU investigation is not a finding of wrongdoing, and no one has been charged.
A municipality that cannot afford mistakes
Matlosana, whose main town is Klerksdorp, is not a council with room for error. It is under a mandatory financial recovery plan after years of maladministration. Its unauthorised, irregular, fruitless and wasteful expenditure had reached R10.8 billion by 2024/25, and it takes about 600 days to pay its creditors, GroundUp reported.
The pattern is national. The Auditor-General found that municipalities and their entities ran up R145 billion in irregular expenditure between 2021/22 and 2024/25, and that breaches of procurement and contract management rules accounted for 87% of it.
Security contracts are a recurring weak point. Guarding is labour-heavy, hard to monitor from a distance and easy to bill for. As the DFFE case shows, a company can be paid for armed guards it cannot supply, by a control room it cannot run, long after the warnings start.
The questions no one has answered
Matlosana and Seametso did not respond to GroundUp's questions, sent from 29 October. Dephetogo did not respond either. In 2025 the DFFE declined to answer GroundUp's questions on the contract, citing pending labour and litigation proceedings.
What remains unknown: what checks Matlosana ran on the company's record before choosing it, who the other three providers are, what the three-month deviation will cost, and whether the officials overseeing the municipality's recovery plan were consulted.
The appointment runs for three months. The municipality has not said whether the appeals will be decided by then, or what it will do about its guards if they are not.
References
- GroundUp (via AllAfrica): "City of Matlosana signs deal with dodgy security company" https://allafrica.com/stories/202611030288.html
- GroundUp: "Forestry Department awarded R140-million tender to dodgy security company" https://groundup.news/article/dffe-awarded-dodgy-tender-worth-over-r140-million-to-security-company
- Morar Incorporated forensic report FC 130 (DFFE, via GroundUp) https://groundup.news/media/uploads/documents/dffe_-_investigation_report_fc_130_-_june_2024_1.pdf
- DFFE termination letter, 29 December 2023 (via GroundUp) https://groundup.news/media/uploads/documents/termination_letter_dephethogo_1_1.pdf
- Knysna-Plett Herald: "President Ramaphosa authorises SIU investigation into Knysna Municipality security tender" https://www.knysnaplettherald.com/News/Article/Local-News/pres-ramaphosa-authorises-siu-investigation-into-knysna-municipality-security-tender-202608130854
- TimesLIVE: "Municipalities spend R1.6bn on consultants" https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2026-06-24-municipalities-spend-r16bn-on-consultants/



