Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga told a Hawks investigator at the Madlanga Commission on Friday that the Hawks made "a very glaring mistake" in a sting operation linked to an alleged R1.5 million theft by a Johannesburg Metropolitan Police Department (JMPD) officer.

Warrant Officer Phuti Mashala, the first witness on the day the commission turned to alleged crime and corruption in the JMPD, accepted that telling someone linked to the alleged bribe about the planned operation was an error. He denied that it was the only reason the operation failed.

The case

The case concerns a roadside stop in August 2023 in which a businessman says a JMPD officer found about R1.5 million in cash in a bag, accused him of money laundering and left with the bag. The officer, Eric Mphahlele, is accused of taking the money. The allegations are untested in court as far as this article's sources show, and he is presumed innocent unless a court finds otherwise.

Mashala testified that he was offered R250,000 to make the docket disappear. The Hawks then sought approval for an entrapment operation under section 252A of the Criminal Procedure Act, in which officers play along with a bribe to catch suspects in the act.

What Madlanga said

Madlanga said that once a person linked to the bribe was told about the operation, they would not cooperate, and the people behind the bribe would either withdraw or keep the money. He said this was "defeating the very purpose of what you sought to achieve." He also told the witness: "It just doesn't make sense at all to me."

What Mashala said

Mashala said: "It might be where we made a mistake of telling her." He told the commission that investigators had assumed the person shared their understanding of the operation. He argued the operation would have been compromised in any case.

What we do not yet know

  • Reports of the testimony differ on exactly who was told about the operation. The commission transcript will settle this.
  • Whether anyone beyond the accused officer has been, or will be, charged over the bribe offer.
  • The outcome of the case against the officer. We have seen one report that he was later convicted of bribery, but we could not confirm it and have not relied on it.