Developing story: Clive Naicker's evidence is continuing. The allegations below have not been tested.
The Madlanga Commission of Inquiry has ruled that parts of the testimony of businessman Clive Naicker, described as an alleged Crime Intelligence informant, will be heard in camera. The commission resumed on Monday 16 November 2026 at the Brigitte Mabandla Justice College in Pretoria.
What stays public and what goes private
The private portions cover Mr Naicker's interactions with members of the South African Police Service and criminal cases in which he is currently a witness. The ruling followed an application for all of his testimony to be heard in camera. The reasons for the ruling were not given in the reports we reviewed.
Evidence about his relationship with the late Bevan Loftus will be heard in public, the commission ruled. So will questions about his business activities and alleged payments to police officers.
The allegations
According to a report of the proceedings, Mr Naicker is accused of orchestrating a hit on Mr Loftus in April 2023. It is alleged that he paid police officers R2.5 million to have a criminal rival murdered, and that Deena Govender, then a Hawks officer, was allegedly involved in carrying out the hit.
These allegations have not been tested before the commission. We have not seen a response from Mr Govender.
An in-camera application
Earlier on Monday, a report said a businessman who has been a registered SAPS informant for more than a decade was expected to bring an in-camera application before the commission, and described him as an alleged Crime Intelligence informant. The report did not name him in the text we reviewed, and it is not confirmed that this is the application that led to the ruling on Mr Naicker's evidence.
What we do not yet know
- The commission's reasons for hearing parts of the evidence in private.
- What Mr Naicker has said in the public portion of his testimony.
- How he responds to the allegations about payments to police officers.



