More than a decade after officers beat him in a police holding cell, a man has been awarded about R2.43 million in damages from the Minister of Police.
The South Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg, in a judgment by Judge A Millar, ordered the Minister of Police to pay R2,432,014.57, plus interest and the costs of the case, to Siyabulela Sompondo. The judgment settles how much he is owed. In September 2019 the court had already found the Minister vicariously liable for the assault.
What happened
On 3 November 2014, officers at Krugersdorp Police Station took Sompondo from his holding cell and assaulted him in an unoccupied cell, according to the judgment as reported. They were trying to make him name suspected co-perpetrators in a robbery.
The assault left him reliant on crutches until October 2015. He later needed hip surgery. Psychiatric evaluations linked the ordeal to his depression and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
How the award was worked out
- R900,859.50 for future healthcare, including hip revision surgery, rehabilitation and psychiatric care.
- R981,155.07 for past and future lost income, after a 65% contingency reduction.
- R550,000 in general damages for pain and emotional trauma.
Medical experts attributed the deterioration of Sompondo's hip equally to the beating and to his long-term alcohol use, according to the judgment as reported. The court took that into account in assessing the claim.
What we do not yet know
- The date of the judgment, which the report we reviewed does not give.
- Whether the Minister of Police or the South African Police Service (SAPS) will appeal or has responded.
- Whether any of the officers involved faced criminal charges or disciplinary action.



