Parliament's police committee on Wednesday blocked a special adviser to acting Police Minister Firoz Cachalia from addressing MPs on the department's plan to reset policing, after members argued that a minister's adviser has no executive authority to answer to Parliament.

Gareth Newham, who was directly involved in drafting the new policing strategy, was expected to brief the committee on the reset agenda and offer technical insight. Committee chairperson Ian Cameron upheld objections from members before Newham could speak, saying he wanted to avoid setting a wrong precedent. Only a senior police official was allowed to brief the committee, according to a report of the meeting.

What MPs said

EFF MP Muzi Khoza raised the first objection. "We can't be addressed by your advisor," he told the meeting, adding that advisers "don't hold any executive authority to account to Parliament."

Committee member Bongani Mkhongi agreed that allowing the briefing would break normal protocol. "I think the argument that says we cannot be addressed by an advisor of a minister is a correct political position," he said.

Why it matters

Advisers sit in a minister's private office, the MPs argued, while it is the minister and the department's accountable officials who answer to Parliament. The ruling means Newham, who helped draft the strategy, did not take part in the briefing.

Separately, Cachalia told the committee on Wednesday that he will appear before the Madlanga Commission on 15 December to share the department's reflections on the reset.

What we do not yet know

  • Whether Newham will be given another opportunity to address MPs, or whether the committee will ask the minister to present the strategy himself.
  • What the senior police official told the committee about the reset agenda.
  • Whether the ministry will respond to the committee's ruling.