Developing story: The tribunal has made no findings, and the hearing continues.
The registry clerk who accuses Eastern Cape Judge Belinda Hartle of racial abuse has admitted lying under oath about phone calls with the judge's husband, the Judicial Conduct Tribunal heard on Thursday, 12 November.
Evidence leader Advocate Benny Kalakgosi told the tribunal that clerk Thozamile Semekazi admitted lying about three phone calls with Ray Hartle, a journalist and the judge's husband. Semekazi had denied on Wednesday, 11 November, that he was in contact with Ray Hartle before a news report on an anonymous allegation that he had solicited bribes. Kalakgosi said Semekazi confirmed he initiated the first call himself and said he lied because of safety concerns.
The allegation and the response
Semekazi alleges that Judge Hartle swore at him and used the k-word in her secretary's office in May 2025. Hartle denies using the k-word. She admits using a swear word out of frustration that files were handed in late, but says it was not directed at him.
Hartle's lawyers have suggested the complaint was an "act of reprisal" after Ray Hartle reported the bribery allegation, which Semekazi denied. Presiding Justice Boissie Mbha ruled that recordings of the calls could not be played to the tribunal, not even in camera. He described Semekazi as a whistleblower.
On Thursday, proceedings were delayed after "death threats" were posted on the hearing's livestream. Semekazi said he was willing to continue his cross-examination. Asked whether he would revise the description of Hartle in his complaint to the Judicial Service Commission, he replied: "I will never change it." He was excused on Thursday afternoon.
What the tribunal heard on Friday
- Denim Kroqwana, the Eastern Cape director of court operations, testified that Semekazi came to his office in tears on 15 May and reported insults, but did not mention a racial slur. He said he was surprised to see the slur in Semekazi's written grievance. He said he heard nothing from the secretary's office, which is separated from his by drywall.
- Under cross-examination, Semekazi conceded that the alleged tirade probably lasted five minutes. He had earlier said it lasted five to ten minutes. Hartle's counsel argued that the alleged words could not have taken even a minute.
- At lunchtime the tribunal went in camera to consider Semekazi's confidential medical records. Justice Mbha said the records were confidential and the proceedings continued behind closed doors.
What we do not yet know
- The tribunal is due to sit for three days next week. Exact dates have not been confirmed.
- The tribunal has not yet made any finding on the allegations or on the credibility of any witness.
- Whether the evidence about the phone calls will affect the weight the tribunal gives to the complaint.
Judge Hartle is presumed to have acted properly unless the tribunal finds otherwise. The allegations are contested.



