The question before three judges in Johannesburg this week is narrow in law and enormous in consequence: when someone who entered South Africa illegally is detained and then says they want asylum, must they be released?
A full bench of the Johannesburg High Court, including Judge President Aubrey Ledwaba and Judge Lebogang Modiba, is hearing a three-day matter brought by foreign nationals held in immigration detention, among them a group transferred to the Lindela Repatriation Centre after serving sentences for illegal entry. The matter involves 33 foreign nationals in all.
The applicants' case
Lawyers for the detainees argue that once a person expresses an intention to seek asylum, the Refugees Act must take precedence, regardless of how they entered the country or whether they were convicted under the Immigration Act. One counsel, Thato Madubanya, argued that such a person should be treated as a de facto refugee, and that there is no other law that justifies keeping them detained once that intention is expressed.
Ntshuxeko Chauke, representing four Ethiopian nationals and one from the Democratic Republic of Congo, took aim at an earlier ruling by Judge Mandlenkosi Motha that allowed asylum applications to be processed while applicants remained in detention. He argued it revived principles other courts had already rejected. He said his clients had repeatedly said they wanted asylum but were never helped to apply when they arrived.
The State's case
Counsel for the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), William Mokhari, argued that the asylum system cannot become a last-minute escape route for people caught without papers. "We're dealing with catch me if you can. If you catch me, I apply for asylum," he told the court.
The NPA's position is that authorities must help people apply for asylum, but that the law does not require them to be released while they wait to do so formally. It said the 48-hour rule still applies, so any detention beyond that needs a magistrate's authorisation, and argued that this is consistent with international refugee law, including article 31 of the 1951 Refugee Convention.
What the judges asked
The bench pushed back on the idea that detention must end immediately. Judges raised the risk of abuse of the asylum process, the State's ability to trace people once released, and whether a bare statement of intent, without more, is enough. Judge Modiba noted there is "no outright prohibition on the detention of asylum seekers" in the Refugee Convention. Judge President Ledwaba asked a practical question about people with no fixed address: "Where will they be residing?"
Why it matters
The ruling will shape how police, the Border Management Authority and Home Affairs handle thousands of arrests. It sits at a point of real tension: South Africa's legal duty not to return people to persecution, and the State's need to enforce immigration law in a country where migration has become a flashpoint for anger and, at times, violence.
Both concerns are real. The court's job is to decide where the line falls, according to the law rather than the mood outside.



