For many South Africans, a meal out is a small treat squeezed out of a tight month. So the last thing anyone wants at the end of it is a charge on the bill they never agreed to pay.
That is what the National Consumer Tribunal has now ruled against. It found that a Pretoria restaurant, Tribeca Standard, broke the Consumer Protection Act by automatically adding a 10% "discretionary" service charge to customers' bills.
What happened
The National Consumer Commission (NCC) investigated after receiving a tip-off that the restaurant, operated by a company called TotaFin, was adding the 10% fee to bills as a matter of course. According to the case as reported, the menu said a discretionary charge of 10% would be added, and that management would remove it if asked.
The restaurant told the Commission it processed about 200 of these service-charge transactions a day. Because of that scale, the Commission treated it as a systemic practice rather than a one-off.
The tribunal declared the practice prohibited conduct. It found that customers should not have to challenge a charge that has been added automatically in order to avoid paying it. The Act says a supplier may not make a consumer pay more than the displayed price.
The Commission had asked for a fine of R1 million. The tribunal declared the conduct prohibited but did not impose a fine or a costs order. It took into account that the restaurant cooperated, stopped adding the charge, removed the wording from its menu, and that the money had gone to waiters, according to reports of the ruling.
"We welcome this ruling as it really confirms the provisions of section 23 subsection 6a of the Consumer Protection Act," said NCC spokesperson Phetho Ntaba. "It has always been our understanding that consumers must pay the price they see."
What this means for you
- Tipping is still your choice. Restaurants may accept voluntary tips, but the decision to tip belongs to the customer. A tip cannot be added to the bill automatically.
- Check the bill. If a service fee appears that you did not agree to, you can ask for it to be removed. You do not have to complain about the service to do so.
- Charges for services must be clear upfront. The Act does not stop restaurants from charging for services, but those services and the full price must be displayed so you can decide before you order.
- If a restaurant refuses, you can report it to the National Consumer Commission.
The NCC says it plans nationwide inspections in the coming months to check that businesses are following the rules.
And the waiters?
Many waiters in South Africa depend heavily on tips to make ends meet, and service charges are often how large groups make sure staff are paid fairly. Nothing in the ruling stops diners from tipping well. What it says is that the choice, and the amount, must be the customer's.
What we do not yet know
- The exact date the ruling was handed down has not been made public in the reports we have seen.
- It is not yet clear how many other restaurants add similar automatic charges, or which areas the NCC's inspections will cover first.



